New Multiyear Data Show Dow AgroSciences SmartStax® Continues to Provide Consistent Control of Above-ground Corn Insects
Posted on Wednesday, March 28th, 2012
The data highlighted below reinforces that even growers in areas without rootworm pressure can benefit from SmartStax® technology. Offering a good value and the most complete protection from above-ground insects, SmartStax has advantages unmatched by other trait technologies, including multiple modes of action and protection from WBCW and BCW.
Four years of data reinforce that Dow AgroSciences SmartStax® continues to provide consistent, effective control of a broad spectrum of above-ground insects in corn. Dow AgroSciences and university trials showed that damage from black cutworm (BCW), western bean cutworm (WBCW), corn earworm (CEW) and fall armyworm (FAW) is significantly lower on plants with SmartStax technology compared with single-mode-of-action or non-Bt hybrids. Multiyear data released in December also show SmartStax continues to provide effective corn rootworm control.
“Data from 2011 builds on previous years’ results that show SmartStax keeps insect damage below economic thresholds to protect whole-farm yield potential,” says Cole Hansen, Dow AgroSciences traits marketing manager. “Protection from the broadest spectrum of insects also means corn growers can have peace of mind that their crop is protected — especially from insects migrating into new territories.”
Black cutworm Data from 2008 to 2011 across 15 locations show that corn stands of non-Bt hybrids were reduced by nearly 36 percent when infested with BCW larvae. Plots planted to Dow AgroSciences SmartStax experienced only a slight stand reduction of 8.5 percent (Figure A).
Central Illinois corn grower Chuck Trainor lost more than half of the rows he planted with a non-SmartStax hybrid when a BCW outbreak occurred on his farm in 2011. The rows in the same field that were planted with Dow AgroSciences SmartStax® remained intact with minimal damage.
“We did some population counts, and they were about 15,000 plants per acre (in the non-SmartStax strips). We could have potentially lost $700 per acre if we had not come back and replanted another (hybrid). And we still will have some lost revenue due to the later planting date on the second corn,” Trainor says.
Fall armyworm Multiple generations of FAW can feed on a corn crop in one season. Dow AgroSciences SmartStax provides season-long protection from this insect, which feeds on leaves. In field trials across 24 locations over four years, Dow AgroSciences SmartStax hybrids received only a 0.4 rating on the FAW scale1 of 0 to 9 — a minor injury caused by FAW consuming leaf tissue until a lethal dose of the protein is ingested. Non-Bt hybrids received an average 4.6 rating (Figure B) with damage ranging from several elongated lesions 1.3 to 2.5 cm long on whorl and furl leaves to elongated lesions longer than 2.5 cm and small- to midsized holes eaten from the whorl or furl leaves.
Western bean cutworm “WBCW feeds on developing tassels, silks and, eventually, kernels — directly impacting yield,” says Dwain Rule, Dow AgroSciences biology team leader. “This pest has gradually migrated east over the past several years, and now corn growers in states as far east as Pennsylvania and New York are starting to see western bean cutworm show up in their fields.”
Trials from 11 locations over four years showed that Dow AgroSciences SmartStax® is effective at controlling WBCW and protecting yield potential by limiting the number of kernels consumed on each ear. In the study, an average of only one kernel on the SmartStax ears was consumed, while 15.7 kernels on the non-Bt hybrid were consumed (Figure C).
Corn earworm Like WBCW, CEW also directly impacts yield potential when it feeds on developing kernels. SmartStax has outstanding protection against this insect, allowing an average loss of only 2.5 kernels per ear compared with 17.4 kernels on non-Bt hybrids (Figure D) across 23 locations from 2008 to 2011.